Get the Beam Out
“Judge not” is about knee-jerk judgmentalism. The plank-eyed hypocrite doesn’t get the joke; he is the joke.
If John 3:16 bibrefjohn3 bibrefjohn3v16 is the most quoted verse in the Bible, Matthew 7:1 bibrefmatthew7 bibrefmatthew7v1 must be the most misquoted half verse. Even though the KJV gets tagged as tough to read, people have no difficulty repeating: “Judge not.”
As the rest of the paragraph (Matthew 7:1-5 bibrefmatthew7 bibrefmatthew7v1 bibrefmatthew7v2 bibrefmatthew7v3 bibrefmatthew7v4 bibrefmatthew7v5) makes clear, this is not about covering your eyes and turning off your brain, but it’s about knee-jerk—emphasis on the jerk—judgmentalism. It’s about being quick to climb to the top rope and jump off with a bionic (or ironic) elbow of superiority.
Verse 2 points out that hyper-critical judgments are like a blind man throwing boomerangs; they come back and hit hard.
Verse 3 points out how ridiculous/laughable it often is: he’s got a log in his eye. It’s impossibly absurd. A “log” (ESV), “plank” (NIV), or “beam” (KJV) is a big piece of heavy timber, the kind that holds up a roof, bigger than a man’s whole head.
The analogy is hyperbole, and humorous. It’s a joke. The plank-eyed man is somehow focused on another man with a speck or splinter in his eye. Verse 4 continues the joke: how can you even see around the log? It’s funny, and it’s hypocrisy. The hypocrite doesn’t get the joke; he is the joke.
So it’s not no judging (see verse 5), but rather it’s no judging from self-righteousness. It’s no judging others first. Brothers, get the beam out.